1962

Richie Ashburn - OF

1963

Duke Snider - OF

1964

Ron Hunt - 2B

1965

Ed Kranepool - P

1966

Ron Hunt - 2B

1967

Tom Seaver - P

1968

Jerry Koosman - P
Jerry Grote - C
Tom Seaver - P

1969

Cleon Jones - OF
Jerry Koosman - P
Tom Seaver - P

1970

Bud Harrelson - SS
Gil Hodges - Manager
Tom Seaver - P

1971

Bud Harrelson - SS
Tom Seaver - P

1972

Willie Mays - OF
Tug McGraw - P
Tom Seaver - P

1973

Willie Mays - OF
Tom Seaver - P

1974

Yogi Berra - Manager
Jerry Grote - C
Jon Matlack - P

1975

Jon Matlack - P
Tom Seaver - P

1976

Dave Kingman - OF
Jon Matlack - P
Tom Seaver - P

1977

John Stearns - C

1978

Pat Zachry - P

1979

Lee Mazzilli - OF
John Stearns - C

1980

John Stearns - C

1981

Joel Youngblood - P

1982

John Stearns - C

1983

Jesse Orosco - P

1984

Dwight Gooden - P
Keith Hernandez - 1B
Jesse Orosco - P
Darryl Strawberry - OF

1985

Gary Carter - C
Ron Darling - P
Dwight Gooden - P
Darryl Strawberry - OF

1986

Gary Carter - C
Keith Hernandez - 1B
Sid Fernandez - P
Dwight Gooden - P
Darryl Strawberry - OF

1987

Davey Johnson - Manager
Gary Carter - C
Sid Fernandez - P
Keith Hernandez - 1B
Darryl Strawberry - OF

1988

Gary Carter - C
David Cone - P
Dwight Gooden - P
Darryl Strawberry - OF

1989

Darryl Strawberry - OF

1990

John Franco - P
Frank Viola - P
Darryl Strawberry - OF

1991

Frank Viola - P

1992

David Cone - P

1993

Bobby Bonilla - IF/OF

1994

Bret Saberhagen - P

1995

Bobby Bonilla - IF/OF

1996

Todd Hundley - C
Lance Johnson - OF

1997

Todd Hundley - C
Bobby Jones - P

1998

Mike Piazza - C
Rick Reed - P

1999

Mike Piazza - C

2000

Mike Piazza - C
Edgardo Alfonzo - 2B
Al Leiter - P

2001

Mike Piazza - C
Bobby Valentine - Manager
Rick Reed - P

2002

Mike Piazza - C

2003

Mike Piazza - C
Armando Benitez - P

2004

Mike Piazza - C
Tom Glavine - P